harness vs collar

Dog owners are bound to dog pulling on the leash. It’s a process that takes time whether a dog understands a harness or a collar or not. There are many advantages and disadvantages when you choose between a harness or a collar.

Despite collars being too familiar in use, some dogs are uncomfortable with them. From experience, it’s evident that collars cause health complications for your dog. Some harnesses at times develop the undesired pulling. The most important thing you need in handling your dog is a disciplined tool. You have to use it without inflicting harm or pain on your dog.

To make a perfect choice, you have to consider these three aspects:

  • The dogs breed.

  • Medical condition.

  • Desired behavior to train your dog.

The following options will provide the best dog handling equipment.

The Collar

A collar is a good option for sensitive dogs. Collars can cause protruding of eyeballs from their sockets and neck injuries. Collars are not suitable for dogs with respiratory issues like pug. It’s thought that frequent use of collars causes spinal complications. They damage the trachea and the thyroid.

Collars are convenient for large dogs that are always outside. These dogs shouldn’t have any respiratory issues. Collars don’t get tangled in long hairs with ease as harnesses, so they are ideal for dogs with long coats.

All dogs that spend most of their time outside need collars to repel ticks and fleas. It’s good to adjust your dog on a collar. Make the dog feel comfortable when having a collar. Inquire from your vet if it’s possible to use an anti-tick collar.

dog collar vs harness

The Use Of A Harness

The use of a harness is excellent for puppies while teaching them how to walk on a leash.

When choosing between back attaching and front attaching harnesses, you should be careful. Harnesses prevent dogs from jumping on people or running around. Harnesses tangle with no pain, unlike collars.

Small breed dogs are susceptible to pressure. It makes the back attaching the harness to be the best. When a dog experiences complication on leash walking, use the front attaching harness.

Front attaching harnesses are very painful compared to back attaching harnesses. Back attaching harnesses are not helpful when you need to discipline your dog. Delicate breeds with respiratory complications should use the back clip harness.

For dogs struggling with behavior issues, front attaching harnesses are suitable for training purposes. It is recommended to switch back to the back, attaching one within a short period.

Deciding to switch from harnesses to collars won’t solve the behavioral issues of a dog. It’s the role of the owner to teach the dog mannerism. Training your dog should be your priority.

Realize your set goal of instilling good behavior in a dog without using forceful ways. The use of chockers is one of the violent ways. It’s advisable to spend quality time with your dog.

Always apply positive reinforcement where necessary.

dog harness versus collar

The Hybrid Choice-The Head Halter

When you have a large dog that is problematic in disciplining using a harness or a collar, try this head halter. It’s a bet option compared to a chocker. The head halter resembles the Fabric muzzle. It comes from fabric that goes around the back head and another strap around the muzzle.

A head halter provides an optimal blend for dog harnesses and collars. It can correct behavioral issues and restraint that harnesses and collars can’t.

Head halter is ordinary in camels than dogs. You should ensure it fits well and in the correct way. When using the tool to achieve your set goal, tug in a gentle way.

dog harness or collar


Always ensure your dog is well trained when opting for the above options. For city dwellers, streets aren’t safe for you and the dog. They need a well-trained dog that will retrieve on command when awaken by an instinct to chase prey. Always use a leash when in the city environment. Large dogs need to be active. Please make sure they are free to run in certain designated areas.


Always remember to tag your dog. If you use a harness, ensure the dog has a collar tag with a name at all times. A chip may not help much in case your dog runs away. It’s easy for anyone who meets the dog to detect it’s a lost dog when it has a tag than when it has a chip.

Always have treats when you go out with your dog. Treats are influential in getting the dog’s attention. It happens when dogs’ instincts overpower the training.

For hunting dogs like beagles, the embodiment is deep in their DNA and has higher chances to chase prey while on the streets. Ensure you teach them how to behave on a leash as you wait for the green light. Always train your dog in a pain-free manner.